Corrugated ECT Chart vs Mullen for Corrugated Boxes

Procurement and packaging teams often face damaged shipments, high costs, or compliance issues when the wrong box standard is used. A corrugated ECT chart helps determine the stacking strength of boxes, ensuring product safety, shipping efficiency, and cost control.

‍

Among the various standards, the two most widely used are the Edge Crush Test (ECT) and the Mullen Test. At first glance, both appear to measure the strength of corrugated packaging. However, the way they test performance, the type of data they provide, and the applications they serve are quite different. 

‍

This guide explains the difference between ECT and Mullen testing in detail. It covers definitions, testing methods, use cases, cost factors, industry preferences, and decision-making criteria. 

‍

Key Takeaways:

‍

• A corrugated ECT chart helps determine stacking strength, making it ideal for warehousing, pallet loads, and retail distribution.
• The Mullen test chart measures burst resistance, preferred for heavy-duty, industrial, and export packaging.
• ECT-rated boxes are lighter, cost-efficient, and eco-friendly, while Mullen-rated boxes are stronger, more durable, and better for high-risk shipments.
• There is no direct conversion between ECT and Mullen since they measure different performance factors.
• Many industries use both ratings strategically: ECT for domestic/lightweight shipments and Mullen for heavy-duty/export needs.

‍

To start, let’s look at the corrugated ECT chart.

‍

What is Corrugated ECT Chart?

‍

The Edge Crush Test (ECT) measures how much pressure a box’s edge can withstand before collapsing. It reflects the vertical stacking strength of corrugated board, making it crucial for storage and shipping where pallets are stacked.

‍

A Corrugated ECT Chart helps packaging and procurement teams quickly identify the stacking strength of various corrugated boxes. 

‍

The chart shows the maximum load a box can handle based on its ECT rating, making it easier to choose the right box for storage, shipping, and pallet stacking. 

‍

Using the below corrugated ECT chart ensures product safety, cost efficiency, and supports sustainable packaging choices.

‍

‍

Pro Tip: ECT-rated boxes typically weigh less than other boxes of equivalent strength because they use lighter material while maintaining stacking strength. This makes them more sustainable and cost-effective.

‍

Types of ECT Ratings:

‍

‍

Technical Specifications:

• Measurement: Pounds per square inch (lb/in) of edge pressure.
• Testing Method: Compressive force is applied until the board fails.
• Box Construction: Often associated with lighter liners compared to Mullen-rated boxes.
• Performance: Focused on vertical stacking strength rather than puncture resistance.

‍

Common Applications:

• E-commerce packaging for clothing, books, and small electronics.
• Retail shipments requiring pallet stacking in warehouses.
• Distribution hubs where boxes face vertical compression during storage.
• Food and beverage products packed in cases and stacked for transport.

‍

Ideal when combined with Standard Carton Sealing and carton sealing tapes to secure packages efficiently.

‍

Advantages of ECT

• Cost Efficiency: Uses lighter board grades, which lowers both packaging and shipping costs.
• Sustainability: Requires less fiber, supporting green logistics and reducing carbon footprint.
• Stacking Strength: Performs well in warehouse environments with multiple layers of pallet loads.
• Carrier Compliance: Meets requirements of major carriers such as Amazon, UPS, and FedEx.
• Versatility: Works across different product categories and distribution models

‍

Need expert guidance on choosing the right boxes and packaging materials for your operations? 

‍

Connect with John Maye Company today to explore ECT boxes, carton sealing tapes, stretch films, plastic strapping, and other industrial packaging solutions designed to keep your shipments safe and cost-effective.

‍

What is the Mullen Test Chart?

‍

The Mullen Test is a performance standard used for corrugated boxes to measure burst or puncture resistance. It determines the amount of pressure a box can withstand before the board ruptures. 

‍

A Mullen Test Chart provides a quick reference for the burst or puncture strength of corrugated boxes. It shows the maximum load a box can withstand before the board ruptures, helping teams select the right box for heavy-duty shipments or long-distance transport. 

‍

Using the chart ensures product safety, durability, and reliable performance for industrial, export, or high-risk applications.

‍

‍

Pro Tip: Mullen-rated boxes use thicker liners and multi-wall construction to resist punctures, making them ideal for heavy or industrial shipments. Pairing these boxes with plastic strapping, steel strapping, or strapping machines bundling ensures maximum security during transit.

‍

Types of Mullen Ratings:

‍

‍

Technical Specifications:

• Measurement: Pounds per square inch (lb/in²) of burst strength.
• Testing Method: Hydraulic or pneumatic pressure is applied until the board ruptures.
• Box Construction: Typically involves thicker liners and multi-wall construction.
• Performance: Focused on puncture resistance and load protection rather than stacking strength.

‍

Common Applications:

• Heavy machinery and industrial equipment shipments.
• Defense and aerospace components requiring secure transport.
• Agricultural products and large tools prone to rough handling.
• Export packaging where long-distance transport increases risk of damage.

‍

Advantages of Mullen-Rated Boxes

• Superior Durability: Designed to resist punctures, tears, and bursting under pressure.
• Protection for Heavy Loads: Ideal for dense or fragile products that need extra safety.
• Compliance for High-Risk Shipments: Meets industry standards for defense, aerospace, and export packaging.
• Reliable for Long-Distance Transport: Maintains integrity during international shipping and handling.
• Versatile Strength Options: Available in multiple burst strength levels to match shipment requirements.

‍

If you need expert support, the team at John Maye Company offers guidance and a wide range of corrugated solutions. From heavy-duty cartons to complementary packaging materials, we help ensure your shipments remain secure and cost-effective.

‍

Now that you’ve seen how each test works individually, here’s a side-by-side comparison of ECT and Mullen ratings to highlight their strengths and ideal applications.

‍

Also Read: Difference Between Stretch Film and Shrink Wrap

‍

Corrugated ECT Vs Mullen Test Chart: Key Comparison

‍

Box performance varies depending on shipment requirements. ECT-rated boxes provide strong stacking strength, suitable for heavy pallet loads and warehouse storage. Mullen-rated boxes offer high burst resistance, protecting fragile or dense products from punctures and impacts. 

‍

This chart shows load capacities and ratings for single, double, and triple-wall boxes, helping industries optimize safety, material use, and costs.

‍

‍

Pro Tip: ECT boxes typically weigh less than equivalent Mullen-rated boxes because they use lighter material while maintaining stacking strength. This makes them more sustainable and cost-effective

‍

Beyond the charts, the real difference lies in how each test measures performance, construction, and cost. Here’s a detailed breakdown to make it clear.

‍

Key Differences Between Edge Crush Test (ECT) and Mullen

‍

Although both ECT and Mullen ratings measure corrugated board strength, they focus on different performance attributes. Packaging teams must consider not just the rating but also factors like product weight, shipping conditions, handling risks, and cost efficiency.

‍

Here is a detailed breakdown.

‍

‍

Quick Guidance:

‍

• ECT: Best for vertical stacking in warehouses, light-to-medium products, and standard logistics. Combine with carton sealing tapes, stretch films, or Protective Paper Rolls to enhance packaging integrity.
  
  
• Mullen: Best for high-risk shipments requiring burst protection. Combine with OB560N, plastic strapping, STEEL STRAPPING, and MIP™ strapping tools for industrial-grade security.

‍

Ultimately, the choice between ECT and Mullen depends on your shipment’s weight, handling risks, and budget. Here’s how to determine which option aligns with your operation.

‍

Also Read: Guide to Choosing the Right Stretch Wrap Gauge

‍

How to Choose the Right Corrugated Box for Your Operation

‍

Selecting between ECT and Mullen-rated boxes isn’t just about cost. It’s about balancing product weight, shipment risk, handling environment, and budget. Here are the main considerations:

‍

When To Choose ECT:

‍

• You need reliable stacking strength for pallets in warehouses or distribution centers.
• Your products are lightweight or uniform, like apparel, books, or small electronics.
• Domestic shipping or controlled handling environments are the main concern.
• Cost efficiency and material savings are priorities.
• Basic protection against vertical compression and minor impacts is sufficient.
• Best for retail distribution, and standard logistics operations.
• Combined with Standard Carton Sealing, carton sealing tapes, or plastic strapping for secure shipping.

‍

When To Choose Mullen:

‍

• Your shipments are heavy, fragile, or high-risk, like machinery, industrial tools, or export goods.
• Products require puncture and burst resistance during transport or long-distance shipping.
• International freight, rough handling, or multi-modal shipping is involved.
• Extra durability is worth the higher material and packaging cost.
• You need maximum protection against impact, punctures, or heavy stacking.
• Best for industrial, aerospace, defense, and export packaging applications.

‍

Pro Tip: Sometimes, the best solution is not purely ECT or Mullen. Many operations use ECT for standard domestic shipments and Mullen for heavy-duty or export shipments to balance cost with protection.

‍

Once you know the right standard, the next step is finding a packaging partner who can deliver reliable solutions. That’s where John Maye Company comes in.

‍

How John Maye Company Helps?

‍

When it comes to industrial corrugated packaging, John Maye Company is a trusted partner across the US. They provide:

‍

• Full range of ECT and Mullen-rated boxes for light, medium, and heavy-duty shipments
• Fast 24-hour order fulfillment for over 2,500 SKUs
• Expert guidance on product weight, shipping methods, pallet stacking, and cost optimization
• Access to packaging consumables such as Standard Carton Sealing, carton sealing tapes, stretch films, AIRplus, Flexible protective packaging, and Quick Shrink 201

‍

Connect with John Maye Company today to explore solutions for plastic strapping, strapping machines bundling, steelflex stretch film, and plastic tools to ensure your shipments are safe, cost-effective, and industry-compliant.

‍

FAQs

‍

1. What does 32 ECT mean in corrugated packaging?

32 ECT indicates that a box can withstand 32 pounds of pressure per inch on its edge before collapsing. It’s the standard rating for most e-commerce and retail shipments that require stacking strength.

‍

2. Can I convert ECT values to Mullen ratings?

No. ECT measures edge compression strength, while Mullen tests burst resistance. Since they evaluate different performance factors, there’s no direct conversion between the two.

‍

3. Which is more cost-effective: ECT or Mullen?

ECT-rated boxes are typically more economical because they use lighter board grades that cut both packaging and freight costs. Mullen-rated boxes cost more due to heavier liners and thicker materials.

‍

4. Do e-commerce companies prefer ECT or Mullen?

Most e-commerce companies, including Amazon, use ECT-rated boxes. They rely on stacking strength for efficient warehousing and safe delivery through carrier networks.

‍

5. Is Mullen testing still relevant today?

Yes. While ECT dominates online retail, Mullen remains vital for heavy-duty applications like defense, aerospace, and export shipping, where puncture and burst resistance matter most.